New York HR compliance guide comparing NY Paid Family Leave and federal FMLA for employers

New York Paid Family Leave vs FMLA: Running Concurrently

New York employers face a unique compliance challenge. The state’s Paid Family Leave program is one of the most generous in the country. Federal FMLA adds its own layer of requirements on top. Managing both correctly requires understanding how they interact — and where they diverge.

Many HR managers in New York treat NY PFL and federal FMLA as separate programs requiring separate administration. In many cases they are right. In others the two laws run concurrently and must be tracked together. Here is a clear guide to navigating both.

What New York Paid Family Leave covers

New York PFL provides eligible employees with paid, job-protected leave for three qualifying reasons. First, bonding with a newly born, adopted, or fostered child. Second, caring for a family member with a serious health condition. Third, qualifying military exigencies when a family member is deployed abroad on active military service.

Notice what is not on that list. NY PFL does not cover leave for the employee’s own serious health condition. This is a fundamental difference from federal FMLA, which covers the employee’s own condition as a primary qualifying reason. An employee who needs leave for their own health condition may qualify for federal FMLA but will not qualify for NY PFL unless they also have a qualifying family care need.

Who qualifies for NY PFL

NY PFL covers most private employers in New York State regardless of size. This is broader than federal FMLA, which only covers employers with 50 or more employees. A New York employer with 10 employees has full NY PFL obligations even though they have no federal FMLA obligations.

Employees qualify for NY PFL after working for the employer for 26 consecutive weeks if they work 20 or more hours per week. Part-time employees who work fewer than 20 hours per week qualify after working 175 days. This is different from federal FMLA’s 12-month and 1,250-hour thresholds.

NY PFL is funded entirely through employee payroll deductions. Employers do not contribute to the cost of the benefit. Employees contribute a small percentage of their weekly wages up to the statewide average weekly wage.

How much leave and pay NY PFL provides

In 2025 NY PFL provides up to 12 weeks of paid leave. The benefit amount equals 67 percent of the employee’s average weekly wage up to a cap based on the statewide average weekly wage.

The leave is job-protected. Employees who take NY PFL have the right to return to the same or a comparable position. Their health insurance must continue during the leave on the same terms as before, though employees may be required to continue paying their share of premiums.

When NY PFL and FMLA run concurrently

When an employee’s leave qualifies under both NY PFL and federal FMLA, the two programs run at the same time. The employer must designate the leave under both laws simultaneously. The 12 weeks count down together rather than one after the other.

For example, a New York employee who takes leave to care for a seriously ill parent qualifies under both NY PFL and federal FMLA. Both entitlements run concurrently. The employee receives NY PFL wage replacement benefits while the leave counts against their federal FMLA entitlement at the same time.

Concurrent running is the default rule when both laws apply. Employers cannot require employees to exhaust one entitlement before beginning the other when the leave qualifies under both.

When only NY PFL applies

Several situations trigger NY PFL without triggering federal FMLA. Understanding these situations prevents compliance errors.

First, NY PFL covers employers with fewer than 50 employees. Those employers have NY PFL obligations but no federal FMLA obligations. Leave for those employees is governed entirely by NY PFL.

Second, NY PFL covers employees who have not yet met federal FMLA eligibility requirements. A New York employee who has worked 26 consecutive weeks but fewer than 12 months qualifies for NY PFL but not federal FMLA. Their leave runs under NY PFL only.

Third, NY PFL covers a broader range of family members than federal FMLA. NY PFL covers leave to care for a domestic partner. Federal FMLA does not. Leave to care for a domestic partner runs under NY PFL only and does not count against the federal FMLA entitlement.

When only FMLA applies

Federal FMLA covers situations that NY PFL does not. The most important example is the employee’s own serious health condition.

When a New York employee takes leave for their own serious health condition, that leave qualifies for federal FMLA protection. It does not qualify for NY PFL benefits. The employee receives federal FMLA job protection but no NY PFL wage replacement. They may be able to use New York State disability benefits or accrued paid leave for wage replacement during this type of leave.

Coordinating paid leave substitution

Under federal FMLA, employers can require employees to use accrued paid leave concurrently with FMLA leave. Under NY PFL, the rules around paid leave substitution are more nuanced.

Employers cannot require employees to use accrued paid leave concurrently with NY PFL. Employees may choose to supplement their NY PFL benefits with accrued paid leave to receive full pay during the leave. However, the total combined benefit cannot exceed the employee’s regular weekly wage.

This creates an administrative coordination challenge. For leave that runs under both programs simultaneously, you must track federal FMLA paid leave substitution rules and NY PFL paid leave coordination rules separately.

Notice requirements under NY PFL

NY PFL has its own notice requirements that operate alongside federal FMLA requirements. Employers must display a NY PFL notice in the workplace. They must provide written notice of NY PFL rights to new employees. They must also provide NY PFL information in any employee handbook.

When an employee requests leave that may qualify under NY PFL, you must provide them with the appropriate NY PFL forms within three business days. This is different from the five-business-day clock under federal FMLA.

Practical steps for New York HR teams

Managing NY PFL and federal FMLA together requires a clear process. For every leave request, determine which laws apply. Designate under all applicable laws simultaneously. Track both entitlements separately where they diverge.

Keep NY PFL and federal FMLA documentation organized and accessible. New York employment law is heavily litigated. A complete paper trail showing you correctly applied both programs protects you in any dispute.

FMLAPro’s leave law maps provide current NY PFL requirements alongside federal FMLA obligations. Client portal subscribers receive real-time updates whenever New York law changes. Visit our store to learn more or contact us with any questions about New York leave compliance.

Scroll to Top